Peerless Rye 3yr

I really started liking Peerless when I tried their 2yr small batch at WhiskeyFest over a year ago and then even more when I tried some of the single barrels at Jack Rose over the summer. Every one I’ve had has been really good for 2yrs but the potential was always higher. At three years is it complete? We shall see…
image1(11)

The bottle design is great, unique, good label, nice cork. The color is dark in the bottle, definitely something that looks good on the shelf.  109.1 proof.

Strong nose but not hot.  Baking spices, cotton candy, Skittles, Cow Tail caramel candy and cinnamon sticks.

Gotta love a non-chill filtered barrel proof rye of this caliber… decent heat but enjoyable, enveloping mouthfeel with good spice.

This is the best three year rye I’ve ever had, much like their two year was the best two year I’ve ever had. But the real question is: is it ready? The answer is yes, but with massive upside.  It’s a wonderful rye and one I’m happy to drink regularly.  The cost is around $110, but full disclosure, I got this one for free from the distillery.  At $110 I would still buy this to drink, just like I did with the 2yr. This is a solid 93/100 but my guess is when Peerless hits year five, Thomas H Handy is going to finally have a peer to contend with.

Advertisements

Lot 40 Cask Strength 2018 Release

This is the second year of the Lot 40 Cask Strength Limited release, coming in at 11 years and 58.4% abv after last year’s 12yr and 55%.image2(4)

First note that hit me was candied orange peel when I first opened this bottle. After some air the orange nose is still present but isn’t overpowering as you get follow through aromas of rock candy, Christmas spices, anise and burned brown sugar in butter sauce.

Really big mouth feel and a lot of heat, much more than the nose suggested. To some this might be too hot and spicy but I enjoyed it, but I’d prefer it not be this sharp and jagged; it probably could have used an extra year in bottle.   Maybe last year’s 12 years was the right number? The finish is long but again, pretty hot to start but does end in a nice lingering sweet and spicy completion—the long and non-bitter finish really is the highlight of the dram. Great mouthfeel and very complex.

This is a really enjoyable rye and a wonderful special release from Lot 40 following up from last year’s incredible first edition. However last year’s was so crazy good the anticipation of this one was so high and it just didn’t quite reach last hear. Last year got a 96 and this one is still good but gets 94/100.

Last year was released at C$60, and this one has been increased to C$100. Still worth it at retail, but if you are looking for secondary, try to find Batch 1 instead.

image1(9)

Woodford Master’s Collection Batch Proof

IMG_0834

Ok…. not sure if Cask strength warrants being an annual special release but I’ll try it anyway.  I also realize that I’ve been accused of being extremely negative recently… I can’t help if I’ve been reviewing or posting about stuff that I don’t like in a row.  Hopefully soon I’ll try something new that I really like.

Bottle looks good and color is attractive.

Cherry wood notes with graham crackers, Twix, dried peach pits, cinnamon sticks and marshmellows. Pretty soft nose for a 125 Proof bourbon.

Decent heat. Enjoyable mouthfeel. Finish is medium. Although nothing special is jumping out. Everything is above average here but not too much above average.

It’s an enjoyable Whiskey. I paid $139.99 for it and I’m pretty confident stating that it’s not worth that.  Every release from ECBP and Barrell Bourbon have been more enjoyable and cost almost half of this. I realize this is a limited release, but everything these days feels like a limited release. Let’s be clear, it is enjoyable and I recommend you get a dram at a bar to try it, but I don’t think it’s anything special that you need to buy a whole bottle. 85/100

Elijah Craig Grenade… I need more!!!

Attention: if anyone is taking a trip to visit Heaven Hill and doesn’t want to buy their one bottle allocation of Elijah Craig Barrel Select 125 Proof “Grenade” please buy it anyway and I will buy it from you at a premium. Yes; it’s that good. Ok, I kind of jumped the gun on the review here, but I’d appreciate you still reading.

IMG_1993

Nice deep amber, cooper color in the grenade barrel 200ml bottle.

Cinnamon sticks, graham crackers, butterscotch, s’mores, vanilla, marzipan and whipped cream. Heat but not too much.

Amazing mouthfeel, complex flavors from the nose, strong Kentucky hug but not overheated. The finish is long and keeps going for over two minutes.

This is so good and the only complaint is that it only comes in a 200ml bottle. I wish they sold these outside of the gift shop. Delicious! 97/100.

Northern Border Collection II: Lot 40 Cask Strength

Part II of my reviews of the Northern Border Collection: Lot 40 Cask Strength 12yr 55% abv. This is the one I’ve been most excited about as I’ve had samples from my friend Mark Bylok—and who doesn’t like a aged high proof rye?

IMG_0067

Copper/dark amber color just reaching out. Sweet, inviting nose of rock candy, cracked pepper, vanilla, baking spices, maple syrup and Christmas trees.

Seriously good on the palate. Coats everything, tingles the tongue, enjoyable but not overpowering warmth and a finish that keeps going on. Sweet and spicy flavors keep going and don’t drop off. The finish is epic… worth leaving in your mouth for a few seconds to get the full flavors before swallowing to realize the total potential.

This is a special whiskey. I am 1/3 through bottle number 2,251 of 4,968. This is better than this year’s Thomas H Handy, but not as good as 2014, 2015 or 2016. It’s in the upper echelons of ryes and deserves to be. I think this is similar but a touch better than the Kentucky Owl rye release. If you can snag one of these for less than 3x retail, it’s worth it. I hope they release it again next year. 96/100.

For a more in depth review, check out Mark Bylok’s Piece: http://whisky.buzz/blog/lot-no-40-100-rye-cask-strength-12-year-old-review

http://whisky.buzz/blog/the-insider-story-of-the-evolving-lot-no-40-canadian-rye-whisky

http://whisky.buzz/blog/eager-for-lot-no-40-cask-strength-heres-your-best-bet-on-getting-a-bottle

http://www.canadianwhisky.org/reviews/lot-no-40-cask-strength-55.html

http://www.lcbo.com/lcbo/product/lot-no-40-cask-strength-canadian-whisky/541326#.Wko7tYVh-Qs

Quick Angel’s Envy Cask Strength 2015 Review: Strong PASS

I’ve never been a huge fan of the AECS, I thought the 2014 was ok, but I’ll give 2015 a whirl. Sickly sweet port nose, and a ton of heat. The taste is dominated by heat as well with some raisins, plums and menthol. This is extremely bad value for the price but I wouldn’t buy it if it was 1/4 the cost, which was $179.99.

The 2015 was much worse than the 2014 and another massive disappointment… just because it’s cask strength, limited edition and in an expensive box, doesn’t make it great.  It just makes it expensive.  The port finish on this is so poor, it seems like now that they sold the company, they aren’t even trying anymore.  78/100.

IMG_1087

Wild Turkey Rare Breed

I’ve heard a lot of good things about Wild Turkey’s Rare Breed from friends in the bourbon community, yet for some reason I never tried it… until now.  Widely available, barrel proof, uncut, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey… what’s not to love?

Nice looking bottle, medium amber color.

Hot nose, ginger snap cookies, baking spices, dried orange peels, cooked mushrooms and forest floor.

Enjoyable mouthfeel.  Light tannins, medium oils, totally enveloping.  The heat is still strong, yet the finish is medium length but dries out and becomes slightly bitter.

For a cask strength bourbon, it’s certainly hard to find one under $50 (at least now that Booker’s is going up in price).  But from the ones that are readily available on the shelves, like Booker’s Barrell Bourbon, single Barrel Four Roses, Rare Breed falls short of them.  I’m not sure why so many people get excited about this, but maybe it’s because they haven’t tried the other cask strength ones on the market?  Rare Breed gets extra points for the price, but once this bottle is gone, I won’t be replacing it.  84/100.

img_0368