Foursquare 2004 vs 2005, Fred Minnick’s Top Rum of 2018

I’m completely #RumCurious thanks to Fred Minnick.  It will never take over Bourbon for me, but it’s great in its own right and worth adding to the cabinet. I loved Foursquare 2004 and I’m hoping the 2005 is as good because I’m down to my last inch of the 2004 bottle. 2005 looks darker.

img_3778

2004 nose is distinctly rum with spicy notes intertwined, pinapple, rose petal, vanilla and caramel.

2005 also is clearly rum with the coconut and molasses notes strong but there is a second wave that had bourbon butterscotch aromas clearly obtained from the cask. Amazing how it doesn’t feel hot even though 59% abv.

2005 The mouthfeel is delightful, focused on the tip of the tongue with rough sweetness and followed through down the middle just kissing the side of the mouth with a juiciness of tropical flavor. The finish is at least two minutes and never drops off. Very good.

2004 mouthfeel coats the whole mouth with significant time spent on the roof with more earthy focus rather than tropical. This may be because this bottle has been open for more than six months though. Like the 2005 this finish is long, but just under two minutes.

With a year that so many followups have not been as good as the year before, this is a pleasant surprise. The 2005 equals and maybe surpasses the 2004 just a little bit. 95.5/100.  Thank you Foursquare!

QUICK Review from a bar… Willett XCF, what PHC 12 should have been

This is basically what PHC12 should have been… the notes are literally identical in terms of items, but the intensity is the difference.  The whiskey is both good, but the orange isn’t a bomb, it’s subtle and woven well.  PHC12 is barely drinkable, this is very delightful (still not worth the secondary price though).  91/100.

https://newbourbondrinker.wordpress.com/2018/11/04/i-love-parkers-heritage-collection-i-dont-like-this-release-though/

img_3963

Lot 40 Cask Strength 2018 Release

This is the second year of the Lot 40 Cask Strength Limited release, coming in at 11 years and 58.4% abv after last year’s 12yr and 55%.image2(4)

First note that hit me was candied orange peel when I first opened this bottle. After some air the orange nose is still present but isn’t overpowering as you get follow through aromas of rock candy, Christmas spices, anise and burned brown sugar in butter sauce.

Really big mouth feel and a lot of heat, much more than the nose suggested. To some this might be too hot and spicy but I enjoyed it, but I’d prefer it not be this sharp and jagged; it probably could have used an extra year in bottle.   Maybe last year’s 12 years was the right number? The finish is long but again, pretty hot to start but does end in a nice lingering sweet and spicy completion—the long and non-bitter finish really is the highlight of the dram. Great mouthfeel and very complex.

This is a really enjoyable rye and a wonderful special release from Lot 40 following up from last year’s incredible first edition. However last year’s was so crazy good the anticipation of this one was so high and it just didn’t quite reach last hear. Last year got a 96 and this one is still good but gets 94/100.

Last year was released at C$60, and this one has been increased to C$100. Still worth it at retail, but if you are looking for secondary, try to find Batch 1 instead.

image1(9)

Canadian Club 40yr Review

Beautiful presentation with the box and bottle and nice rope neck.  Thick glass.  Classy and looks great on the shelf.

Pale color whiskey, with strong maple syrup and vanilla nose with Necco wafers and a touch of toffee on the back.

Good mouthfeel given the proof, initially very smooth but the baking spices build up enjoyably throughout the sip with a medium mouthfeel.

It’s not great, but it’s very good.  The JP Wiser’s 35yr release is significantly better.  However, for a 40yr whiskey, it holds its own and it very enjoyable.  90/100

IMG_2804

I still hate this store… Grand Central Cellars

Buffalo Trace 750ml $75…

IMG_2858(2)

Pappy 23 Gold Wax… $10,500…

IMG_2859(2)

2017 BTAC George T. Stagg $650…

IMG_2860(2)

Pikesville Rye at least they reduced that price from $125 to $80!!!

https://newbourbondrinker.wordpress.com/2016/10/08/shame-shame-nyc-central-cellars-wine-spirits-shame/

But before they went to $80 from $125, then stopped at $105…

https://newbourbondrinker.wordpress.com/2016/12/28/central-cellars-wine-spirits-price-reductions/

The argument people tell me “oh, it’s high rent, they need to charge more”… that argument is defeated with these three photos… if you can’t sell something for $125, or $105, maybe you can sell it for $80, or maybe you won’t sell it at all and you will go bankrupt…

IMG_2857(2)

Sorry for being so negative, but they guys consistently overprice stuff and I know their rent is high, but I never see any of the bottles gone… so if your rent is high, and your prices are high and you only sell cheap rose and champagne for people who need them and the bourbon just sits there… how are you still in business?  Sorry for the rant.  Have a nice day.

IMG_2861(2)

Elijah Craig 18 Barrel 4339 Review

EC18 Single Barrel #4339 bottled 2/4/17 review… this is one of the best values out there in Bourbon world, but how did this single barrel stack up?

Mushroom, forest floor, hints of butterscotch, and a medicinal undertone on the nose, following up with cedar woodiness.

Good mouthfeel, but not amazing due to chill filtering, however the taste builds up nicely with toffee in the background and overwhelming umami sensory experience.

It’s not the best EC18 I’ve had, but it’s solid and hard to beat for a 18yr Bourbon.  92/100

IMG_2806

Little Book Batch 002 Noe Easy Way

Last year’s release of Little Book Batch 001 was a solid release but priced appropriately at retail that it didn’t make much of a splash on the secondary. Seems that I liked it more than the average consumer, giving it a 92/100 (Batch 001 Link). It had lots of complex spiciness with a good finish but was on the hotter side—not uncommon with Booker products. This edition is totally different. 8yr Kentucky Straight Rye, 13yr Canadian Rye and a 40yr old Canadian corn whiskey. 118 Proof, uncut, unfiltered. For those hoping for a big Kentucky Bourbon, they may be disappointed, but anyone who had last year’s Northern Border Collection releases (Link 1 and Link 2) will know better.

Side by side you can see the color difference. Batch one has the copper notes, while Batch 002 has a softer, lighter, amber tone. The bottle and box look great.

The nose is moderately hot, spice coming through, rock candy, candy corn and some light caramel. The taste is really good, lots of all-spice, enjoyable wood hints and a really long finish. Easily two minutes or more ending with a nice Kentucky hug, but more moderate than the nose would imply.

Batch Two, Noe Easy Way, is a very good follow through from Batch 001. Given the 40yr juice in this I could also see it trading up in the secondary. It’s very good and absolutely worth adding to your collection. 94/100.