It’s the NBA finals tonight so I decided to pull out the CEHT Straight Rye Bottled in Bond. Colonel E.H. Taylor is one of the renowned Buffalo Trace brands, coming out with several very limited editions in addition to their highly allocated normal line which includes their straight rye. I’ve been drinking a lot of rye recently, mostly Thomas H Handy (another BT product and part of the annual BTAC release) and Pikesville, the new release from Heaven Hill. I’m hoping the Taylor rye lives up to its allocated hype.
The packaging of all the Colonel Taylor whiskeys are gorgeous–this is no exception. The tube is great, the mock tax stamp looks classic and the label is always a looker. The color is medium amber.
The nose is hot, which is standard for the CEHT line, and not surprising for a 100 proof whiskey. I get notes of rock candy, candy corn, buttered raisin bagel and cinnamon sticks.
The palate has some of the heat from the nose and some of the flavors but the mouthfeel is thin, tannins are lacking and the finish is moderate at best. It’s enjoyable to drink but is just lacking complexity and is missing the finish that I was expecting.
If you find one of these bottles at retail price on the shelf I would still buy it, but mostly because it is so hard to find (read: trade bait), but in terms of drinking there are better options out there. I pulled my Pikesville off the shelf for a quick comparison: even though the proof is ten higher, the nose is more interesting, the taste is better and smoother, the finish is substantially longer and it is cheaper. If you are looking for a great rye, buy Thomas H Handy. But if you can’t find it or don’t want to pay $300 secondary market costs, buy the Pikesville Rye, it is better in pretty much every way and it costs less. I also pulled out my Sazerac and I think I actually prefer it to the Taylor as well and it is basically 1/3 the price. CEHT Straight Rye is fine to drink, but there are so many better options out there at better price points. 86/100.