The 21 Club in NYC found a few cases of Prohibition Era whiskey a few years ago and now they are down to just a couple bottles. It is Hiram Walker Private Stock Blended Canadian Whiskey from Walkerville, Ontario, Canada–it looks like like Canadian Club. Distilled in 1919, aged for 10 years in barrels and bottled in 1929, this whiskey has continued to mellow in the brown bottle for the last 87 years. Initially very skeptical about paying up for something like this, however, I am glad I went ahead and bought it.
The color was lighter than a bourbon, but on par with a Canadian Whiskey aged in used barrels. The nose was all Madagascar Vanilla, uber velvety and oozing of smoothness. The second draw had cinnamon sticks, cotton candy, with a steam shower water vapor-esque consistency which was just so light and fresh. The nose was not overpowering at all, but so gentle and unique I could only hope the taste equaled.
At 90.4 proof I had lower expectations for the palate and mouthfeel, but oils on the mouth came in nicely, although any remnants of tannins were long gone if they ever were present to begin with. Vanilla clouds permeated through each sip, and this was one you wanted to keep in your mouth for a long time to get every nuance. Something about 87 years in the bottle after 10 years in wood really did some magic with this whiskey.
If you are in NYC you need to go to the 21 Club and order it. On the menu it is $100, but if you ask Anthony nicely for a half pour, then may give you a full one for $50. At $50 I would buy this every single time. Hard to grade something that isn’t readily available, but I feel comfortable giving it a 98/100.