After this one, only one to go to complete the current Orphan Barrel series, and thus far I have been pretty disappointed. Largely it has been because the costs have been so high… all have been interesting in their own way, but none of have had any real value to them. This week I saw a blog that said Orphan Barrel has just had their TTB label approved for Whoop & Holler, a 28 year whiskey. My guess is that it will also be an overoaked, not exciting bourbon, yet I will still try to buy 3 of them and will be first in line to buy it. I will act like a Mets fan in April, self-imposed ignorantly excited, ready to open my wallet for September tickets, only to subconsciously know I will be disappointed again and should clearly know better. But Hope Springs Eternal, and that’s how I feel when I try Lost Prophet. As a Yankees fan I should know better….
When I first opened the bottle and it needed some air… Very flat on the open so I let it sit for 15 minutes. Seriously folks, we need to do some research on this first open bottle thing…
Color looks like a black tea with two bags….
Interesting spicy nose, Necco wafers, cloves, Skippy Chunky Peanut Butter, toasted buttered cinnamon raisin bagel… Mild heat on the nose.
Very smooth, yet spicy palate. Very tasty but the finish is just okay, and not as long as I would have hoped. The mouthfeel is good but not great. The nose teased me, but the taste just didn’t follow through. So many great bourbons have finishes that last for one, two, three minutes or more… this was barely 15 seconds.
Thus far, Lost Prophet is my favorite of the Orphan Barrel series but given the price, it’s just not a must own. For value, Forged Oak is probably better, and given that it’s much cheaper and easier to find, if you feel to need to buy one of these, go for that one. Overall, this is enjoyable, but if you don’t get to taste it, I wouldn’t lose any sleep over it. 89/100.